This tutorial will walk you through the filters specific to Commodity ETFs you can choose from when screening for Commodity ETFs. AlphaBeta ETF identifies Commodity Type of Commodity ETFs and Direct vs Indirect Commodity Exposure as the foundation to look for the right Commodity ETF for you.
What are the Commodity-specific filters I can use?
Direct Exposure via Commodity ETFs: Provide immediate access to the price movements of raw materials by holding the underlying commodity through physical storage or synthetic derivatives like futures contracts.
Precious Metal
Description: High-value assets like gold and silver primarily used for wealth preservation and jewelry.
Example: SPDR Gold Minishares Trust [GLDM]
Industrial Metal
Description: Also known as Base Metals, such as copper and aluminum, which are essential for construction and continuing green energy transition.
Energy
Description: Encompassing crude oil, natural gas, and refined products that power global transport and industry.
Example: United States Oil Fund LP [USO]
Agriculture
Description: Includes commodities like wheat, corn, and livestock vital to the global food supply chain.
Example: Invesco DB Agriculture Fund [DBA]
Indirect Exposure via Commodity-related Equity ETFs: Rather than tracking the price of the physical goods, indirect exposure is achieved through Equity ETFs (instead of Commodity ETFs) that invest in the companies responsible for producing and processing these materials. This includes firms such as Metal Miners and Oil Exploration and Production companies. These ETFs are usually categorized within the Materials or Energy sectors of the stock market.
Description: Commodity-related Equity ETFs are influenced not only by commodity prices but also by corporate earnings, management efficiency, and broader equity market sentiment. While they often move in tandem with the underlying commodity, they can offer additional growth potential through dividends and operational leverage.
Example: VanEck Gold Miners ETF [GDX]
How to pick the right combination of the above Commodity-specific considerations?
Understanding your exposures
⬤
Direct Exposure via Commodity ETFs: For Commodity ETFs that hold physical assets or futures, the primary driver of returns is the balance between global supply and demand for each specific commodity. These drivers are highly specialized. For instance, energy prices are sensitive to geopolitical stability and OPEC+ quotas, industrial metals respond to infrastructure spending and the pace of the green transition, and agricultural products are dictated by weather patterns and trade policies. These ETFs are betting on the scarcity or abundance of the raw material itself, rather than the business success of the companies that produce them.
⬤
Direct vs Indirect Exposure to Commodity: Choosing between a direct commodity ETF and an indirect commodity-related equity ETF requires an assessment of corporate fundamentals that go beyond the spot price. Indirect exposure through miners or energy producers introduces operating margin and operating leverage, where small changes in commodity prices can lead to outsized gains or losses in company profits. Furthermore, these equity ETFs are subject to supply volume and extraction issues (e.g. labor strikes or mine depletion), country risk regarding the location of physical operations, and traditional equity valuation metrics like P/E ratios.
Macroeconomic conditions
Macroeconomy and market conditions: Common considerations and comparisons include geopolitical stability, monetary and fiscal policies, and economic cycle.
Geopolitical Stability
Commodity markets are highly sensitive to geopolitical stability, as the production of energy, metals and other commodities is often concentrated in specific geographic regions. Tensions or trade realignments can lead to sudden supply shocks, causing price spikes in direct-exposure ETFs or creating operational hurdles for companies in indirect-exposure equity ETFs.
Monetary and Fiscal Policies
Commodity prices are intrinsically linked to the strength of the currency in which they are priced, most commonly the U.S. Dollar. Expansionary monetary policies with lower interest rates or significant fiscal stimulus can lead to currency depreciation, which typically drives commodity prices higher as they become cheaper for international buyers.
Economic Cycle
The demand for commodities is a leading indicator of the global economic cycle. During the expansionary phases, increased manufacturing and construction activity drive up the prices of cyclical commodities like copper and oil. Conversely, during an economic slowdown, industrial demand tends to wane, though defensive commodities like gold may attract safe-haven flows.